Visit our partners in environmental stewardship

District Municipality of Muskoka Muskoka Water Web

Save Your Trees From Salt Damage

By Rebecca Willison

 

MWC often gets questioned in the spring about why trees along roadways have brown leaves or needles and how this can be avoided. While tree damage from road salt usage doesn’t become obvious until the spring, now is the time to consider ways to minimize damage over the winter.

 

Approximately five million tonnes of road salt are released into the environment in Canada each year. The most commonly used road salt is the same salt that is used on food – sodium chloride.

 

Although road salt assists with keeping pavement dry and safe during the winter and has little negative effect on human health, its widespread use can cause damage to trees, shrubs and other plants along roadways.

 

How salt damages plants

Road salt can damage plants in two ways. The first is through an airborne spray that kills dormant buds by penetrating leaf scars. The second occurs when salt accumulates in the soil where it breaks down into its two components, sodium and chlorine, both of which act differently to affect the plant.

 

In extreme cases, chlorine ions in the soil are taken up by the tree in early spring, where they enter the sap and concentrate in shoots, preventing bud openings. Eventually, the chlorine is transported to actively growing leaf margins where it causes leaf scorch, curling and death.

 

Sodium ions in the soil follow the same route as the tree’s nutrients, blocking magnesium and potassium, both of which are necessary for the production of chlorophyll. Again, in extreme cases, this can result in a potassium deficiency that may inhibit the tree’s resistance to drought and disease.

 

Salt accumulation in the soil can also cause a physiological drought. Salt solution near tree roots is more concentrated than the tree’s sap, impeding osmosis and preventing the tree from taking up water through its roots.

 

In general, the primary long-term damage to salt-weakened plants is a result of their increased susceptibility to insects, pathogens, and the environmental stress of drought, wind and ice. Tree death from road salt is less common.

 

Symptoms of salt damage

Salt damage to conifers is most noticeable in the spring. Branches closest to the road get yellow and brown needles that drop off. This colour change starts at the tips of the needles and progresses to affect the whole needle.

 

In Muskoka, the browning of trees is often noticeable on the east side of Highway 11 during early spring. By summer, these trees have usually recovered and have new green growth. Damage due to salt spray is usually short-term, with long-term damage occurring where the tree is under other stress.

 

Deciduous trees damaged from road salt may have many twigs densely clustered together, called witches’ brooms, near the ends of branches as a result of terminal buds killed by salt spray. Other symptoms include unopened flower buds, twig dieback, sparse, stunted or yellow foliage, and leaf scorch.

 

Young trees are more susceptible to salt damage because they have fewer roots than older ones.

 

Preventing salt damage to your trees

There are several ways that you can reduce the damaging effects of salt on your trees.

  • Avoid the use of de-icing salts. Use coarse sand to help make driveways and sidewalks less slippery. If salt must be used, use as little as possible, lower the throwing distance, and apply before the area freezes.
  • Keep your trees and shrubs healthy. A healthy plant is better equipped to survive salt spray and accumulation in the soil.
  • Plant salt-tolerant trees near roadways and walkways. Some salt-tolerant native species include Red pine, Red oak, ashes, birches and poplars. Salt-intolerant species, such as White pine, Sugar maple, Eastern hemlock, basswood, and spruce, should not be planted near areas where salt is used.
  • Use barriers to protect sensitive species from salt damage. Barriers may include plastic fencing, snow fencing, or burlap.
  • Improve the drainage around trees or adjust the grade so salt is easily leached away from the trees.
  • Flush the soil with water in the spring when it thaws so salts are sent beyond the trees’ root zones.

Until a cost-effective alternative to the use of conventional road salts is developed to keep our roads safe in the winter, reducing the amount of salt applied and minimizing salt damage to our trees and our watersheds is the best course of action.

 

 

Past articles are available in this blog under the Watershed Notes Articles category or under Past Articles in the Resources section.

Share this! Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on StumbleUponShare on TumblrEmail this to someone
This entry was posted in Watershed Notes Articles. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Save Your Trees From Salt Damage

  1. dimalick@aol.com says:

    What can I do for tree suffering from salt on roads. I live in Chicago

  2. admin says:

    For an urban area like Chicago, your best option is to replace the affected trees with native or non-invasive species that are more salt tolerant. For trees already affected, flushing the soil around the tree with water each spring may help to dilute the salt concentration in the soil and allow the tree to recuperate. Healthy trees (i.e. not suffering from disease, pests, drought, etc) are better able to recover from salt damage than trees that are stressed.

  3. denise johnson says:

    What other products (aside from sand) that could be used to de-ice the snow but wouldn’t damages the trees? Will the so-called Magic Salt still have negative effect on trees too? Thanks anyway for sharing this information.

  4. admin says:

    It is suggested that using non-chloride based de-icers such as acetates or formates (with Calcium magnesium acetate being the most studied) will reduce the environmental impact. Two good articles with additional suggestions are ‘Minimizing De-Icing Salt Injury to Trees’ (http://www.extension.umn.edu/distribution/naturalresources/DD1413.html) and ‘Gardener, Spare That Tree (From Salt Damage)’ (http://www.nytimes.com/1989/02/23/garden/gardener-spare-that-tree-from-salt-damage.html).

    As for your question about “Magic Salt’ and other similar products, keep in mind that they are basicaly rock salt (sodium chloride) with a pre-wetting agent (usually magnesium chloride), so you are essentially still putting chloride into your soil, where it may affect your trees. You can check out the MSDS for “Magic Salt” at http://www.meltsnow.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/MAGIC_SALT_MSDS-_MSWS_2010.pdf. Note that under Ecotoxicity, the sheet states: “May be harmful to freshwater aquatic species and plants that are not tolerant to inorganic salts.” A review of “Magic Salt” in another article (http://www.peterschemical.com/magic-salt-fact-or-fiction/) states that “Since Magic Salt is comprised primarily of ordinary road salt, any slight advantage of Magic Salt over ordinary road salt will come from the potential reduction in quantity required. Salt does not break down and the harm it causes to plants is well known. The fermentation byproducts in Magic Salt do not protect plants from the harmful effects of salt.”